Tintern Abbey analysis

Wordsworth did notice that poetry might be able to show what philosophy could only postulate, and that the philosophical poem’s supreme importance lay in fulfilling that office. ‘Tintern Abbey’ poses interpretative problems; the poem’s subtle balance in which Hartleian elements, that look to the British empirical line of thought, is poised against a rhetoric of the sublime.

Read in this following passage that the collectivism of ‘Tintern Abbey’ becomes more comprehensible, its ‘still, sad music of humanity’ a source of happiness not misery for the narrator because its image of the convergence of individuals, the motor-force of the entire poem, predominates over its melancholy. The self’s preparation for this insight has been a progress across time through increasingly refined sensations incorporating rather than eschewing youthful, unrepresentable, animal affinities with nature, a progress itself moving towards a comparable extinction of consciousness signalling unconscious rapport:

‘that serene and blessed mood,
In which the affections gently lead us on, –
Until, the breath of this corporeal frame
And even the motion of our human blood
Almost suspended, we are laid asleep
In body, and become a living soul:

While with an eye made quiet by the power
Of harmony, and the deep power of joy,
We see into the life of things.’           (lines 42-50)

The fact that Wordsworth then redescribes this insight as ‘a sense of sublime/ Of something far more deeply interfused’ indicates once more his Romantic view of how we retain a philosophical interest in areas philosophy points to but cannot itself articulate. The poem is an elegy for an absent cause. Just as his other poem, The Ruined Cottage, it celebrates a humanity characterized by its inability to leave lasting memorials of its intensest feelings. The author discovers authenticity in a loss of individual consciousness, and his poetry expresses his difficult sense that he still remains a match for this new, even fatal expansion.

Tintern Abbey in 1798 was swarming with beggars and the Wye Valley echoed day and night to the sound of ironworks. A poetic vantage-point high enough to continue deaf and blind to this defining uproar is actually the view from nowhere. The poem’s plot, too, is allegedly evasive. Five years back should recall a time when the author was exiled from his new family and wrote a republican pamphlet too treasonable to publish; he suffered a sense of alienation better summed up by the poem he wrote at the time, Salisbury Plain, than by any lines from Tintern Abbey:

‘Oh! dreadful price of being to resign
All that is dear /in/ being! better far
In Want’s most lonely cave till death to pine,
Unseen, unheard, unwatched by any star;’       (lines 306-10)

The poem that replaces this with ‘the hour/ Of thoughtless youth’ and says it ‘cannot paint/ What then I was’ is sublimating history for its own purposes, and discrediting these purposes as a result.

<<back next>>

Hamilton, Paul  ‘Wordsworth and Romaticism’, The Cambridge Companion to Wordsworth, Cambridge Uiversity Press, 2003



Leave a Reply