To A Butterfly
Wordsworth’s Romanticism can figure in those allegedly slighter moments for which he was often taken to task. The lyrics begun in 1802 look modest by comparison with the sonnets of the same year. Poems to daisies, celandines, butterflies, and green linnets, not to mention daffodils, seemed provocative in 1807 when they were included in Poems, in Two Volumes, as ‘Moods of My Own Mind’. Some said that Wordsworth had imposed a metaphysical importance on trivial things. But when in the second poem, ‘To a Butterfly’, Wordsworth compares the alighted creature with ‘not frozen seas/ More motionless’, the complexity of the conceit draws attention to the author’s study at that time of Elizabethan and metaphysical poetry. The imposition of meaning on the insect asks for the conceit to be read through those conventions. The immobility of the butterfly reminds one of so opposite a defining or elemental capacity for flight that it is appropriately described as a fluidity temporarily suspended. But the poem perhaps also anticipates a Tennysonian attention to detail, something characteristic of the Victorian Era. A metaphysical resonance is surely coupled with an observational nicety which, like the later 19th century movement in painting, pre-Raphaelitism, artfully updates a once naive simplicity. Writers of the period such as Schlegel and Stendhal proclaimed all poetry and literature to be romantic. And Wordsworth assimilation here of a scientific niceness to fit a poetic address is as distinctive as his bigger Romantic sketches of natural process, memory and nationhood.
Hamilton, Paul ‘Wordsworth and Romanticism’, The Cambridge Companion to Wordsworth, Cambridge University Press, 2003

Entries (RSS)